BayLobsters Cafe & Fish Market

“Seafood is likely the single most important food one can consume for good health.”

Testimonials

Deb JGreat selection, good meal, a priceless gem!! No need to head to Cleveland any longer!

Teri W The selection is wonderful and the seafood is SUPERB!!

James DFantastic restaurant. First time eating here and it was delicious

Jeffrey E Have bought seafood from here since they opened, but ate in for the first time yesterday. Great food and very fresh, plus friendly staff. We will be back again!

David B— I had the shrimp po’boy and what treat that was! My wife had the fried shrimp, my daughter had the clams, and grandson had the fish and chips. We all enjoyed it. we came in close to closing time and they served us like they just opened up. we will be back!

Wendy C My husband and I had a wonderful lunch, Fish and chips with Bang-bang sauce, lobster bisque, and clam strips. We also brought home some tuna steaks to pan-sear for supper.

Susan M We traveled from Strasburg, Oh. My husband and I had the special of fish and chips. We received more then we expected. A large piece of lightly breaded cod, delicious potatoes, coleslaw, and hush puppies. All for $9.99. We also purchased snow crab and king crab legs which we steamed and feasted on at home. I’m from the east coast and know what good seafood should be like. We look forward to making another trip to Wooster to visit Baylobsters.

 

Thank you for your kind words. If you’d like to submit a testimonial, please fill out the form here!

Rod

Captain and Cindy have been excellent through the years. The new staff are fantastic. You are my favorite small business , and continued success to you

Rod

Felix S.

I have been going to BayLobster since they opened, the seafood is excellent, the service is great and the owners are the nicest people you would ever want to meet. Thanks for bringing fresh seafood to Twinsburg.

Felix S.

Melody K

Excellent seafood, yummy shrimp po boy.

Melody K

Marcy R.

Excellent, Fresh Seafood!

Marcy R.

Jesse B

Love this place

Jesse B

Kelly A

Very fresh fish!

Kelly A

Laura L

They do it right! great service and friendly atmosphere along with great seafood. Can't miss!

Laura L

Jessica L

The cooked to order dishes are AMAZING and perfectly seasoned! Yummy!

Jessica L

Virgina P

Very friendly - ready to help you. great seafood. The place to by live lobster

Virgina P

Andy M

Awesome place for seafood, great prices and tremendous service.

Andy M

Linda M

Everything is really fresh!

Linda M

Carol B

We've never been disappointed by the quality of the seafood we've purchased at Bay Lobsters and we know you'll agree. Give it a try soon.

Carol B

Ronald R

Blue Fish is great. Very friendly and efficient service. Prices very reasonable.

Ronald R

Beth D

The freshest bestest seafood around.

Beth D

Jeff P

Best fish market, hands down. Great product, fantastic people. Fresh, fresh, fresh (the fish, that is!).

Jeff P

Melody M

Ok Cindy Here is the review I promised you for Baylobsters NEW seafood sausages. Italian and Hot Italian. They are spectacular. We Put them on the grill and they were fabulous. I didn't find any difference in taste between the Italian and Hot Italian but there was just a little kick at the end of the Hot Italian. Highly Recommended! THANKS!

Melody M

Ty S

This place is ridiculously good. High quality seafood, great prices, and fantastic customer service. Find this place and go there often.

Ty S

Meredith K

Best seafood around!! Most amazing crab cakes!! I love this place!!

Meredith K

Renee M

Excellent seafood and great recommendations!

Renee M

Cindy B

The Large Red King Crab was perfection. Great Market and we cannot wait to return!

Cindy B

David Y. from Rogers, OH

I'm gonna keep this simple, no bull. Been around the world 3 times, lived in too many places I've lost count (on the coast off the coast)...have never tasted fish and chips of this caliber ANYWHERE!!! Not kidding!!! All of their stuff is awesome, just go and get ANYTHING and you will enjoy. Thanks Captain John...you the man!!!

David Y. from Rogers, OH

The Choudhury family

A shop without which we cannot go by even for a week even though it is 50 minutes drive away. You might wonder why we say that. Let us start from the beginning of our quest for quality food.

“BayLobsters Cafe & Fish Market, a shop without which we cannot go by even for a week even though it is 50 minutes drive away. You might wonder why we say that. Let us start from the beginning of our quest for quality food.

We used to shop for food at other retailers. You can buy more food for less hole in your pocket. We found that quality of food is not bad for the price and also when compared to other grocery chains. Other retailers rip you off especially when it comes to buying fish and the fish stank.

We always went by the equation Fish = Stink based on our experience. Our daughter couldn't touch the fish and I (mom) tried to mask the fish with marinade or condiments. Even then, I had to remove the oil from fish like salmon as it would gag me. Maybe I am not a fish lover but my husband who swears by the fish also had a lot of difficulty ingesting it.

Our quest continued; more holes in our pockets. One day we hit the jackpot. My husband read about this family-owned shop on the internet. See, he is the surfer like fish. We decided to try it out because of all the good reviews but I was skeptical. I am thinking in my mind what condiment should I use to eat the fish from this shop. I am drowning in stink already anyway, how bad can this shop going be?

The D-day: On entering, we noticed that it's truly a fish market unlike some drug stores selling clothes. Our eye caught the plaque which said that fish should smell like ocean. I thought Yeah, right!, fish = stink. We looked at the fish. It seemed fresh and clean; but the price seemed more compared to the membership clubs but at par with the grocery chains. We selected couple of fish like trout, salmon, etc., and when we were done shopping, we were left with less quantity and it was disappointing at first as we had to shell out more than we are used to. At that time, we didn't know any other quality.

When we came home and took the fish out of the package, it didn't smell and it was clean. We just used salt and pepper on the salmon as we wanted to see if the fish was what they say. Before frying, did the gig of lighting the candles, opened the door with the fan pointed outside and we put all the coats in closet. Who wants to smell like fish? We pan-fried the fish. Still no smell. My skeptical mind is like, maybe it's not all smoke and mirrors. Of course, I let my husband try it first and he was like "finally we got something that tastes like fish". Then, it was my turn. I tried a small piece and I couldn't believe what he said was true. It was soft and absolutely delicious. I am like, OMG! This is how salmon tastes. So what were we eating all this time. Also found that the small quantity is quite satisfying. It doesn't matter how much goes in rather what goes in. Both myself and my daughter are fish lovers. She takes fish for lunch, two times a week. We are not only one happy customer but happy parents too. Our quest finally ended with the Best Quality, Best Service and Best Smile from Baylobsters.

The Choudhury family: Customer since beginning 2010 i.e. 88 weeks.

Dorothy

I have been shopping at your store since you were at the old location. I have never had a bad piece of seafood. Lately I have purchased 2 products that were new to me, Barramundi, and the smoked mussels. Both were great. The fish is mild, with a great taste, and according to Dr. Oz, one of the healthiest fish you can buy. The mussels were absolutely delicious. They can be eaten plain as an appetizer with a dip, in a salad, or as I made them, in pasta. Thanks for GOOD healthy eating!!

Dorothy

Thanks!! We love Bay Lobsters! The Larsen’s

My daughter’s 7th birthday is Wednesday and we are celebrating Saturday – her meal of choice?! YOUR LOBSTERS!! BTW, she had Bay Lobster’s lobster for her 6th birthday, too. (Why couldn’t she love HOT DOGS!!)

Thanks!! We love Bay Lobsters! The Larsen’s

Nancy

My husband and I stopped by Bay Lobsters on our way home last night. It was our first visit and we left with Chilean Sea Bass and fish chowder. Oh my, both were fantastic!!! We baked the sea bass in white wine for 20 minutes or so and had a cup of the chowder while we waited. Your chowder is so awesome!!! It could be served in any fine dining establishment and get rave reviews!!! I am allergic to shell fish so I never get to try the seafood type chowders. This is so incredibly good. We are looking forward to becoming regular customers and will tell everyone we know about Bay Lobsters. Thanks for being there!

Nancy

Gordon Glass

I was the gentleman that purchased the 6.1 lb lobster a few Saturdays back. I smoked it on my Weber charcoal grill...indirect heat at 350 f. for 35 minutes. It was very moist with a very unique smoky flavour. I made a bisque with the shells and body meat. I added some crab meat...spectacular!

Gordon Glass

Melanie

We ended up getting the Bay of Fundy salmon for our BBQ on Sat. It really was amazing and so fresh. We loved it, as did our guests. I can't wait to try your Copper River soon. We are so thrilled to have found a great place for fresh fish so close to us. We'll be back!

Melanie

Scott and Diane

Just to let you know….the 7 lobsters we purchased for Mother’s Day last Saturday were AWESOME! Not a drop of water out of them. Mom loved it; despite hating the part where we put them in the pot J Thanks for your wonderful establishment! The Larsens

Scott and Diane

Thanks, Casey

I purchased the Sea Bass on Sunday….AWESOME!!!!! I was hesitant to spend the money and my mother thought I was nuts…I proved her wrong as she’ll be in to purchase some for herself after she tried mine. Before that I had the Orange Roughy which was also wonderful. We are a fish family and live less than a mile away so having your store so close is either going to make me really happy or broke!!!! Looking forward to my next purchase which I’m probably going for Grouper.

Thanks, Casey

Therese Ware

Thank you. The lobsters were great for our New Year’s Eve dinner!

Therese Ware

Pat Pasco

Enclosed is payment for the delivery I received today from you. It looks great! I am sharing some with a neighbor.

Pat Pasco

Lisa

Thanks!! We ordered little neck clams and snow crab legs -- they were delicious. You helped to make my husband's first father's day very enjoyable!!!

Lisa

Edwina O'Rourke

got my vote and comment on line....will continue to do so until there's a line outside your store all the way to 91!! oh, wait a minute.......am i'm ruining things for myself........nah!! :}

Edwina O'Rourke

Thanks for the delivery

Thanks for the delivery of the wonderful haddock. When I was wrapping it in individual wraps for some freezing, I realized how great it was. So I had to have some for dinner. Nothing in the other stores compares. Taste was soooooo good. It took me back to the days in the Gloucester area.


Jim Gibbs

Got your new email about the website change. Looking forward to it! Love your store and have really enjoyed all the seafood I've tried ( several orders) from there. Still want to be included in news... don't take me off the list. These little things you do, like fresh Stone Crab Claws, or live Crawfish, or the homemade clam chowder...make you the best fresh seafood place in the middle of land locked Twinsburg! haha . Please keep doing what you're doing and sending out those email bulletins too!

Jim Gibbs

We never cease to be impressed

We never cease to be impressed with the freshness of John's seafood products. Quality is unbeatable, service is top-notch and pricing is very reasonable.


Richard & Ruth Andrews

We highly recommend that you try John's for the best seafood that we have been able to find in this area.

Richard & Ruth Andrews

Sands

Sitting here enjoying some left overs of that Canadian Salmon. It’s great. Keep up the good work.

Sands

Joe Petzker

We've purchased a great variety from BayLobsters and have enjoyed it all. From Arctic Char to Chilean Sea Bass to Lake Erie Perch to S. African Lobster Tails...it's all been amazing. We drive up from Akron and they carefully pack our order in ice during the hot summer months. Keep it coming BayLobsters! Thanks for the wonderful products...

Joe Petzker

Market Hours

BayLobsters Cafe & Fish Market

3423 Cleveland Rd.,
Wooster, OH 44691
330.601.1200

Winter Hours (Nov - March)
Mon - Thurs 10:30 am - 6:00 pm
Fri 10:30 am - 7:00 pm
Sat 10:30 am – 6:00 pm
Sun Closed - The Lord's Day

Summer Hours (April - October)
Mon - Thurs 10:30 am - 6:30 pm
Fri 10:30 am - 7:30 pm
Sat 10:30 am – 6:00 pm
Sun Closed - The Lord's Day

Email Us!

News

ABOUT OUR FISH/SHELLFISH

Ever wonder about the taste, texture, country of origin, nutrition info, etc. about our fish and shellfish? I did my best to compile all the info for you into easy to read format. This information should help you broaden your seafood horizens.

Click Here!

lobster-roll BayLobsters ~ the best Lobster Roll this side of New England.

Check out this week's email for specials & recipes.

GMO’S?

Do you worry about what's in your fish? Growth hormones, antibiotics? Added colors? No need to worry about this from the fish and many other items at BayLobsters Cafe & Fish Market. Because of the nature of wild fish, you would only need to worry about this issue with any farm-raised fish. All fresh fish and scallops from BayLobsters are all natural without any added chemicals like colors, growth hormones or antibiotics. This gives you healthier meals for you and your family. Most of our fish are also from an MSC Certified Sustainable Fishery.

Click here to check out our Wooster Facebook page.